Gramophone pin fired from a bicycle bell: is it a plausible weapon? (পথের কাঁটা)

One of the most famous Byomkesh Bakshi stories written by Saradindu Bandyopadhyay is Pother Kanta (also transliterated as Pather Kanta, পথের কাঁটা). The story was also exceedingly popular in the Basu Chatterjee-directed television serial aired on Doordarshan.

Most readers (and viewers) are intrigued by the innovative weapon used by the criminal in the story. The use of a standard bicycle bell modified into an air-gun capable of firing a steel gramophone pin (often called  phonograph needle in many parts of the world) captured  the imagination of fans all over the world.

In my own opinion this story ranks up there with “The Speckled Band” which feature Sherlock Holmes in creating a vivid, lingering impression. I enjoyed the concept so much that I actually created the article on Pother Kanta on Wikipedia. We will discuss this story in many articles, but our focus here is on the weapon itself.

Is it physically possible to create a lethal bicycle-bell gun that obeys the laws of physics? This question is vital to fully appreciating the story.

First, let us consider the projectile, the gramophone needle or stylus. Although the use of this sharp object as a weapon is innovative, the use of needles has been attempted many times. The Dreyse needle gun was a breechloading rifle that fired needle-like projectiles in the 1800s. It fell out of favor because of a short-range. Of course this gun had a powder charge, but the reason it was not used frequently was because of short range of accuracy. In Pother Kanta, the assailant fired from a distance of no more than 3-4 meters. In these short distances, sharp needle-like projectiles are very accurate.

In fact, other types of needle-guns have existed for years as well. The benefits of shooting sharp needle like objects is that they have a very high muzzle velocity once fired. Another factor that would allow a bell mechanism to shoot gramophone needles is that recoil from such a weapon would likely be minimum.

In Pother Kanta, a single gramophone needle pierced a victim’s heart at close quarters.  The question of height of the victim comes into play. For victims of different heights, different angles would be necessary, although this could be modified by an expert marksman by tightening the bell. The question of whether the gramophone needle could pierce the sternum is also an interesting one. With sufficient velocity, it is possible that incident ricochet would allow the needle to pierce the heart, although not cleanly. So far, the story is quite accurate.

The other brilliant bit behind the weapon is that because gramophone needles are usually made of steel and other hard metals (as opposed to lead), at close distances and high velocities they might even pierce through and leave through exit wounds. So, no trace of the projectile would be found inside the body!

I have presented a scheme for a possible spring-piston gun mechanism that might be able to propel a gramophone needle towards a victim. Extrapolating from actual data on maximal velocities achieved by firing pellets from spring-piston mechanisms, I have calculated that the bicycle-bell gun might have a probable velocity of 15-20 m/s which would be enough to inflict substantial harm to someone wearing light layers of clothing.

Of course, all of my calculations depend on the assumption that relatively high tensions in the spring can be created to generate sufficient kinetic energy upon release. This is the “black-box” of the whole theory and very hard to determine without computer simulation.

Nonetheless, as I have demonstrated, if we use a bit of imagination, this sort of weapon is plausible.

©2010 All rights reserved.



Filed under পথের কাঁটা, Basic information on this site, Byomkesh stories, Byomkesh trivia, Pother Kanta

8 responses to “Gramophone pin fired from a bicycle bell: is it a plausible weapon? (পথের কাঁটা)

  1. manojit

    I am very luky because I seen this site long time after . this site is very popular.pls. send this video free.

    • Manojit, I will not share materials that are subject to copyright on this website. You can purchase most of the dvds in Bangla from Moserbaer and Angel. The Hindi Byomkesh Bakshi directed by Basu Chatterjee can be easily found elsewhere too. Thanks for reading.

  2. Hats off to you for this effort! I already know you from your blog 🙂

    Can you tell me something. What was Satyavati’s surname before marriage?

  3. Vinod

    Nice one, Thank you 🙂

  4. Aditya

    This is a very clever but superficial .
    As when u look at the original construction of a bell then u’ll see that the striker is not where the needle is present.
    Secondly ,in the story it is said that the culprit shoots straight at the chest then howcome someone can adjust the direction of the handle so accurately to hit exactly at one point in more than two cases.
    Thats completely a hypothesis.

  5. I’ll bookmark this page… Thank you for sharing.

  6. Biplab Das

    Too good. I like it.

  7. This is good, really good! I am inclined to accept this as an explanation. And of course, one mustn’t forget that our murderer would have practiced amply for different heights of targets, before coming out to offer his services. Surely, he would have spent years, if not months, perfecting the machinery of the bell and his shooting skills, no ?

Leave a Reply to Nipon Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s