Comments for Byomkesh.com - ব্যোমকেশ.কম

Comment on Gramophone pin fired from a bicycle bell: is it a plausible weapon? (পথের কাঁটা) by Hal Simpson

Hal Simpson — Wed, 10 Apr 2013 04:17:59 +0000

I’ll bookmark this page… Thank you for sharing.

Comment on Byomkesh visual quiz by Souvik

Souvik — Sat, 16 Mar 2013 06:06:31 +0000

Awesome…;)

Comment on Comparing Byomkesh Bakshi to Sherlock Holmes by Biswarup

Biswarup — Mon, 04 Feb 2013 20:13:29 +0000

jara Byomkesh ke heo korchen tader jonno bole rakhi, sudhumatro niros goenda golpo eti noe,bangla sahitter utkristo gune somriddho rohosso uponnas, bangla sahitter jara samojhdar non tader jonno Byomkesh noe.

Comment on Comparing Byomkesh Bakshi to Sherlock Holmes by Ananya

Ananya — Mon, 21 Jan 2013 14:44:55 +0000

@Aditya: NO detective literature in the entire universe can claim to be one hundred-percent logically accurate. FYI, if you didn’t note, Sherlock Holmes himself was a “copy” of M. Lecoq. And also, almost every detective lit contains a narrator-sidekick, not just Byomkesh. Does that make them all un-original? Must be so in your view. Also, NOT everybody thinks Holmes is the greatest. Many feel he’s overrated. You want illogical? In the “Speckled Band”, the girl is an overly-dumb character who cannot recognize a damn SNAKE when she sees one. Snakes DO NOT drink milk or any other liquid. Un-scientific to the core. Illogical–the very character of Holmes. Somebody who is more of a robot than a human being. Atleast Byomkesh is HUMAN in that sense, he possesses realistic emotions.

Comment on Gramophone pin fired from a bicycle bell: is it a plausible weapon? (পথের কাঁটা) by Aditya

Aditya — Mon, 24 Dec 2012 13:30:42 +0000

This is a very clever but superficial .
As when u look at the original construction of a bell then u’ll see that the striker is not where the needle is present.
Secondly ,in the story it is said that the culprit shoots straight at the chest then howcome someone can adjust the direction of the handle so accurately to hit exactly at one point in more than two cases.
Thats completely a hypothesis.

Comment on Comparing Byomkesh Bakshi to Sherlock Holmes by Aditya

Aditya — Mon, 24 Dec 2012 11:40:10 +0000

Oh C’mon..its utter foolishness to compare an under-average almost copied literature like byomkesh bakshi with Sherlock Holmes.
Sherlock Holmes was being written decades before bromkesh. Shardindu ji copied not only the holmesian deductive methods but had also copied the way of narration. What was the need of Ajit in this. Creativity dies here.

Secondly , the conclusion of byomkesh stories are superficial and without any reasoning. Like in Pother kaanta:
1 first it is said that the criminal would’ve been alone as the accuracy in the shooting was extraordinary.
Now how can someone shoot a gramaphone pin so accurately by a cycle spring mechanism . Ha! Bogus.

Please dont compare such aweful literature with the great worlwide loved Sherlock Holmes!

Comment on Byomkesh: “If you consider it seriously, there can be only one explanation” by Rana

Rana — Thu, 26 Jul 2012 08:59:52 +0000

There is a major flaw in the logic of Chitchor (disclaimer: I haven’t read the story but seen the movie ‘Abar Byomkesh’) It is not clear at all why the bank manager will commit the crimes just to remove pictures of him. Surely a photograph of him will exist in bank records. This is just not a believable plot

Comment on Comparing Byomkesh Bakshi to Sherlock Holmes by Your Dad

Your Dad — Tue, 27 Mar 2012 14:34:27 +0000

copyist!

Comment on Gramophone pin fired from a bicycle bell: is it a plausible weapon? (পথের কাঁটা) by Vinod

Vinod — Thu, 22 Mar 2012 14:00:33 +0000

Nice one, Thank you

Comment on Byomkesh: “If you consider it seriously, there can be only one explanation” by Kaushik Pal Potronobish

Kaushik Pal Potronobish — Tue, 20 Mar 2012 07:47:54 +0000

Chitro Chor is a fabulous piece of fictional writing.